(+86)132-9575-5501   (+86)132-9575-5501  1468319621@qq.com

Skid Steer Loader

You are here: Home » News » Skid steer loaders vs. compact wheel loaders

Skid steer loaders vs. compact wheel loaders

Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2022-11-17      Origin: Site

Even though it is well known that the skid steer loader is popular for its versatile characteristics and always has a good performance within many varieties of construction machines all the time, the compact wheel loader becomes another hot machine and enters the construction site as the loader develops. This article compares skid steer loaders and compact wheel loader machines from ten aspects.

Bucket capacity

Usually, the compact wheel loader holds around 25 per cent more bucket capacity and tipping load. The detailed bucket capacity varies according to model type.

Advantage: compact wheel loader.

WS65-640-640 (2)

Purchase price

Compare the price of skid steer loader and that of compact wheel loader,  the latter's price is higher about 25 per cent than the before. In China, there are a lots of brilliant skid steer loader manufacturers provides competitive price for the products including large skid steer loader, digging machine and so on. Take below company as an example: https://www.forway.com/

Advantage: skid stter loader

WS100-640-640

Operating costs

When users operate the skid stter loaders, they usually find they spend a lot of money in the skid steer loader tires and fuel. Compact wheel loaders is more economical than skid steer loader. Compact wheel loaders have less ground pressure and better traction, so you can start work earlier and work longer under soft ground conditions.

Advantage: compact wheel loader

botcat

                                                         source: botcat company

Horsepower

The more ponies, the more hydraulic horsepower as well. But keep in mind the two machines use their power differently. The skid steer needs the extra horsepower to push itself around, counter-rotate and such. The compact loader transfers power to the ground more efficiently so it can use more power to carry loads, but the skid steer can load its bucket and raise it to the dump height with the engine at low throttle, and power high-demand hydraulic accessories.

In the aspect of horsepower, skid stter loaders indoubtly win in this competition. We take Cat as an example, 262 model has 50% more horsepower over the 904B. Usually, there are more ponies and hydraulic horsepower will also be high.

Advantage: skid steer loader

Speed

The operating speed is faster for compact wheel loader. The Equipment World Spec Guide shows most small loaders offer a travel speed of around 10 to 14 mph while 7 to 10 mph for skid steer loaders. So if you want a more flexible machine, compact wheel loader may be a better choice.

https://www.forway.com/sany-digging-machine.html

Advantage: compact wheel loader

12-640-640

Maneuverability

In terms of maneuverability, the slip loader is the first place in the driving process.

The driver can rotate in reverse on the track, and because of the advantage of low cab height, the slip loader is allowed to operate in a structure with low clearance.

Advantage: skid steer

Maintenance-and-maintenance-of-Ti-Han-skid-steer-loader4

Loading

The skid steer loaders have a hinge pin when in the vertical lift path, so you can dump a bit higher than comparable compact wheel loaders. For compact wheel loaders, the drivers can sit higher. It means the drivers have better visibility when they work.

Advantage: skid steer loaders.

WS65-640-640 (1)

Visibility

The skid stter loaders drivers can see the bucket cutting edge clear and have a good control of it. It is easily for the driver to do more difficult and accurate work.

Advantage: skid steer loaders

WS85-640-640

Operator comfort

Compact wheel loader's side-entry door is easier to get in.  But the skid steer loader's cabs is becoming more and more spacious. So the more space definitely give the more comfortable feeling for the drivers especially in the hot days.

Advantage: skid steer loader

13-640-640


Attachments

Skid steer loaders can be equipped with a variety of attachments for different using purpose. It is like a "transformer" and can do many kinds of construction work and daily clearing work for example shoveling, stacking, lifting, digging, drilling, crushing, grasping, pushing and scraping, loosening soil, trenching and so on.

Advantage: skid steer loader

10-640-640


Inquire Now
Contact us